NARN workshop at CAS Copenhagen 21-22 October 2026.
Talking points. Oral Presentation to Accompany Slide Deck.
The Construction of Nordic Anti-Apartheid History: A Danish Historiographical Critique.

Link to invitation and programme
Link to PowerPoint
Link to abstract
Link to background 5-pages discussion paper
The actual draft of my 40-pages double-article can be accessed on my website under Book manuscripts with a password, but should not be cited before publication.
Slide 1: Title & Methodological Approach
(Slide text: The Construction of Nordic Anti-Apartheid History – A Danish Historiographical Critique of Swedish Approaches)
Dear colleagues and participants.
This paper is perhaps a bit off-agenda—in the sense that it is just as much about past events as it is about the future - and in the sense that it is just as much about Nordic solidarity with Africa as it is about Africa itself. I hope you will forgive me for that.
My input is derived from a longer article I am currently writing on the subject. Some might find my approach more negative than optimistic. I hope to receive some feedback on that.
S2
When we examine the international solidarity movement, the Nordic countries occupy a unique place in both academic literature and popular consciousness. The Scandinavian support is frequently framed as an extraordinary historical chapter—an example of altruistic, state-sanctioned internationalism.
However, today I want to present a more critical, comparative rereading of this historiography. By examining the interconnections between historical writing, grassroots movements, national economic interests, and state foreign policy - my objective is to expose how the narrative of Nordic solidarity was constructed—and, in some instances, distorted.
Slides 2–4: Mapping the Historiographical Field
(Slide text: Nordic Solidarity with South Africa – Selected Authors & National Perspectives)
S3
As both a former activist in the Danish anti-apartheid movement and an academic historian, my perspective is rooted in a critical Danish tradition and my aim is to interrogate how state-funded historiography have created a harmonised, self-congratulatory history. By deconstructing this narrative, we can better understand the power relations which shaped African Studies in this research area in the Nordic and address the hidden agendas that operated behind the banner of international solidarity.
S4
To evaluate how this history has been written, we must look at the writings of some of the key authors.
In Sweden, scholars and institutional figures such as Håkan Thörn, Tor Sellström, Mai Palmberg have dominated the field. Their contributions—most notably the extensive, state-funded research series published through the Nordic Africa Institute (NAI) in Uppsala has been quite influential on the Nordic countries' relationship with Southern Africa.
By comparison, some of the Danish literature, authored by figures like Christopher Morgenstierne, Gorm Gunnarsen, and Peter Tygesen, often reflect a sharper tension between state actions and activist movements.
When we analyse this body of work, an imbalance emerges: Swedish scholars and institutions have set the framework, dictated the scope of inquiry, and established a dominant narrative that to some degree has subordinated the experiences and contributions of neighbouring Nordic countries.
Slide 5: Theme 1 & 2 – Hegemony, Competition, and Research Dominance
(Slide text: Co-operation and Competition Among Nordic Partners)
This brings us directly to a central issue: Swedish dominance in the historiography and the underlying competition among Nordic countries regarding anti-apartheid research.
While the Nordic governments frequently projected a united front of moral superiority, they were also competing for geopolitical influence, trade access, diplomatic prestige, and post-apartheid commercial positions.
This competition shaped national research priorities. History writing became a tool of soft power. Claiming the title of "foremost among equals," Sweden successfully mobilised government research grants, semi-state institutional initiatives and state-sponsored publications to frame Swedish commitment as the primary engine of Nordic solidarity.
The consequence of this Swedish hegemony includes:
Firstly. Self-Referential Sourcing: Swedish historiography - claiming to represent Nordic solidarity - relies overwhelmingly on Swedish sources, but are often treating Swedish experiences as representative of all Scandinavian countries.
Secondly. Harmonisation and Laundering: By framing solidarity through a Swedish lens, these accounts construct an ahistorical, harmonised narrative that sanitises the inadequate sanction policies and ongoing commercial trade maintained by Nordic governments throughout the apartheid era until 1986/87.
Slides 6–7: Critique of Methodology and NGO Literature
(Slide text: State-Sponsored vs. Grassroots Histories)
When evaluating the literature, we must try to distinguish between state-sponsored accounts and independent grassroots histories.
Official and semi-official histories—frequently commissioned or subsidised by government bodies—tend to promote state interests. They often portray academic research as neutral, non-ideological, and objective, while obscuring the political compromises inherent in state policy.
S7
On the other hand, Non-Governmental Organisation (NGO) histories written by anti-apartheid activists can sometimes suffer from narrow-mindedness or self-praise. However, grassroots and left-wing Anti-Apartheid Movements (AAMs) preserve vital historical truths:
- They document true opposition to state foreign policy.
- They highlight historical guilt and shame regarding continued commercial engagement with Pretoria.
- They expose the genuine radicalism of the activists who forced reluctant political elites to act.
A rigorous, source-critical historical investigation must move away from abstract politological generalisations and broad globalisation theories. We must recenter the concrete actions, domestic conflicts, and policy battles radical movements fought that, for a while, pushed Nordic governments to support liberation movements.
Slides 8- (-9) -10: Deconstructing the "Nordic Model" Myth
(Slide text: The Harmonised Narrative vs. Grassroots Activism)
The dominant narrative built by scholars like Tor Sellström and Håkan Thörn relies on three core claims:
- A more or less unified Nordic and global Anti-Apartheid Movement existed.
- Natural harmony prevailed between popular NGOs and Nordic governments.
- Nordic state support was coordinated, unique, and led by a Sweden.
S10
My article seeks to demonstrate that these claims are to some degree ideological fictions.
In reality, there was no single, harmonious "Nordic community" driving a unified foreign policy. In Denmark, for example, there was no seamless "Scandinavian consensus." Instead, intense political conflict existed between grassroots organisations and governments.
Nordic governments introduced effective official sanctions late, while trade with South Africa continued to grow until 1986. State-backed mechanisms for aiding apartheid victims were probably partly established to manage and pacify public opinion rather than to dismantle economic ties with the apartheid regime.
Slide 11–13: Theme 3 & 4 – Co-Optation, Conceptual Blurring, and Hidden Agendas (Slide text: Exposing Hidden Agendas & Government Exploitation)
This leads us to further issues: Namely the government exploitation of grassroots movements and the hidden agendas within state-sanctioned solidarity: Moral Cover and Laundering, Conceptual Blurring and Defecting Altruism.
S12
- By providing a rather modest financial aid to freedom movements, Nordic states created a "fig leaf" of moral solidarity. This allowed them to project progressive values home and abroad while preserving lucrative trade and industrial relationships with South Africa.
S13
- Scholars within this policy-making tradition frequently deploy vague concepts like "civil society" or "globalization from below", which blurs the distinction between profit-driven business lobbies and anti-capitalist grassroots activists, and obscures how state organs co-opted and professionalised NGOs.
- State assistance was rarely purely altruistic. It also served as a strategic investment to build goodwill with "governments-in-waiting" to secure future diplomatic and trade advantages in post-apartheid Southern Africa.
Slides 14–15: The Social Democracy Narrative and Cold War Politics
(Slide text: The Role of the Socialist International and Ideological Framing)
A special feature of Swedish historiography is the overemphasis on Social Democracy and the Socialist International (SI), even if reformist ideology really did not have much influence in Africa during the Cold War
S15
Mainstream accounts highlight the modest consumer boycotts of the early 1960s—a period when the ANC was viewed as less ideologically aligned with the Soviet bloc. Conversely, they understate the widespread, radical grassroot actions of the 1980s led by left-wing, socialist and communist organisations.
Why this specific focus?
Firstly. Promoting the so-called Nordic Model: Emphasising social democratic leadership reinforces the domestic legitimacy of the Swedish welfare state model.
Secondly. Cold War Realpolitik: Social democratic leaders sought to steer the ANC away from communist influence. Highlighting the Scandinavian aid supported the ANC’s post-Soviet transition toward social-democratic politics.
Thirdly. Erasing the Left: Radical left wing and communist activists who drove mobilisation on the ground are downplayed.
Slides 16–17: Invented Preconditions – Colonial Neutrality and the "Missionary Myth" (Slide text: Historical Distortions and Historical Ties)
To explain why Scandinavian states were uniquely positioned to lead transformation and reconstruction, dominant historiography often constructs two historical justifications:
Firstly. The Claim of Non-Colonial Innocence.
Scandinavia is frequently presented as possessing no colonial baggage, placing it closer to African liberation movements than other Western powers. This ignores the history of Danish and Swedish colonial ventures in West Africa, the Caribbean and India, as well as Denmark’s extensive involvement in the transatlantic slave trade that helped fund early industrialisation.
S17
Secondly. The "Missionary Connection".
Some Swedish narratives claim that historical missionary presence in Southern Africa was a key precondition for later political solidarity. Some authors have gone so far as to assert that Denmark provided less direct support to the ANC because it lacked a substantial missionary footprint in the region.
This is a historical distortion. Church institutions both in the North and in the South condemned the liberation movement’s armed struggle for decades. Promoting the "missionary myth" serves a contemporary political purpose: it constructs a historical tie between Sweden and Southern Africa, asserting that Sweden holds a special place in the history of the new South Africa.
Slides 18–19: Conclusions on Swedish Historiography
(Slide text: Welfare State, Movements, and Solidarity – Summary of Critique)
To summarize my critique of the Swedish-dominated anti-apartheid narrative:
- Harmonisation: It presents an uncritical, unified story that gathers all Nordic countries behind Swedish leadership.
- Top-Down Bias: It prioritises state institutions and social democratic histories over grassroots mobilisation.
S19
- Conflict Erasure: It minimises conflict between activists and governments, as well as divisions within the anti-apartheid movement itself.
- Economic Blindspots: It underplays the extent to which ongoing trade with the apartheid regime profited Nordic economies.
- Self-Interest: It ignores how small, allegedly non-colonial states used solidarity to secure long-term geopolitical and economic influence.
Slide 20: Theme 5 – Historical Consciousness and Diplomatic Realities
(Slide text: Institutional Power, Goodwill Tools, and Post-Apartheid Realities)
Finally, we must address a last theme: the consequences of government-supported historiography for historical consciousness and Nordic-South African relations.
The construction of this historical narrative carries tangible real-world consequences:
Firstly. Soft Power and Diplomatic Prestige: Official book series, state-funded conferences, and academic research were utilised as tools of international goodwill. Sweden used its solidarity image in diplomatic negotiations and commercial ventures in post-apartheid South Africa—most notoriously exemplified by the controversial sale of Swedish JAS Gripen fighter jets to South Africa.
Secondly. Institutional Power: Institutions like the Nordic Africa Institute (NAI) in Uppsala operated as central nodes of academic authority. Over time, friction regarding Swedish institutional dominance and research direction led to a more distant Danish attitude.
Thirdly. Perception in South Africa: By dominating the narrative, Sweden successfully positioned itself in public memory as South Africa’s primary Western benefactor.
Slide 21: Conclusion
(Slide text: Reclaiming the Principles of Liberation)
In conclusion: historical writing is never neutral. When governments fund, direct, or co-opt the history of social movements, solidarity can be transformed into an instrument of statecraft and corporate branding.
The task of historians is not to celebrate comfortable national legends, but to apply rigorous source criticism, expose hidden economic and political agendas, and honour the true complexity of international solidarity movements. Reclaiming this history ensures that the history of anti-apartheid support continues to defend the core ideals of the liberation struggle, rather than serving the interests of state diplomacy.
Thank you.